KELTEK & Phuture Noize & Sefa - One Tribe (Defqon.1 2019 Anthem) [Q-dance]

[SKRWD]

I really, really don't like this anthem. As a whole. Sorry to say, but... I would've preferred Phuture Noize's, Keltek's and Sefa's parts as single anthems, like OSTs for Q-Base for example. The concept definitely is cool and something new but I simply don't like how the different parts were put together.

I'll rate each part separately (ratings may differ from time to time):
Phuture Noize: In all honesty, this sounds like a typical 2018 PN track with Defqon.1 vocals in it... Don't get me wrong, Marco is one of the artists I really admire and really look up to and I love each of his productions. But to me it sounds like BMS 2.0... 7.5/10

Keltek: Cool atmosphere and nice melody. Must be one of his best. The true Defqon.1 feeling (at least for me) is here. Nice. 8/10

Sefa: Awesome, and the part I liked the most from the first listens. 9/10

[ThePrincipal]

no thanks..

[Shadder]

Love all the 3 parts, but it's true that the long breaks kill the energy.

But I don't mind it so much since the anthem is more like a showcase, it's not meant to be played in the middle of a set.

Overall I like it a lot It's cool to see Qdance trying new things !

[ceero]

veeeery first listen impression - make 3 separate tunes out of this and it works, i like the Keltek and PN parts (no comment on the Sefa part). They have the Defqon vibe, they are catchy but there is no authentic connection between them whatsoever, it doesnt have a flow. This idea worked with Wolves Cry, but here it just sounds forced and inconsistent, it doesnt sound logical here. Sounds just like swapping three names without a chemistry together in one tune just for the hype. Maaaaybe the PN and Keltek parts would work together if it was arranged a little differently... but than again, if there is frenchcore in a tune it totally kills any overall impression anyway. Well, i'm not really sold unfortunately, i wish they released it as 3 separate tunes - why not? They did something like that with Q-base a lot of times

[Gommes_]

This is not one anthem but but 3 pretty cool tracks. Keltek's part is the best for me!

[VOL-E]

I think this "summer vibe" doesnt fit PN style... thats the result

[Segugio]

Would have been amazing if Keltek did the whole thing.

[solarized]

I agree that it definitely sounds like 3 tracks in one which kind of defeats the point, they should just have had 3 different anthems.

Otherwise, they should release and EP with the anthem as a whole and then each artist has their own edit of their part/version of the anthem, as an extended part, so PN would have two climaxes, etc. That would make sense.

E.g. Because personally I don't really like the KELTEK part tbh, but I really enjoyed the Phuture Noize part so I'd love to hear the Phuture Noize part as it's own track but a longer version, if you get me.

Am i talking rubbish?

[Emre]

Indeed it's a bit long but I don't really experience it as one big mashup, feels glued together quite well so to me it still feels as one complete song. Tho I hate to say it, KELTEK is boring me lately. And the Sefa part is quite happy even for Sefa standards. PN part is FIRE tho. Mixed feelings overall.

[Gracio]

I love this anthem.
All three did a great job and also big kudos to JDX.
Don't complain how long this anthem is, remember DBSTF's Qlimax Anthem? That was 8 minute +.
This anthem goes 9 minutes.
I hope all three cut there own parts out and making extended solo tracks.