
The melody thread (Give feedback before posting yours)
-
- State Celebrity
- Posts: 1923
- Joined: 20 Mar 2011, 14:41
Re: The melody thread (Give feedback before posting yours)
@NRx Hardstyle I like the 2nd one
3rd and 4th are decent but the first and last melo is not my style

Purpose, thou art the compass.
@The Convicted, that third melody is amazing 
@NRx Hardstyle, as Soundphase said, really like the second melody
here's some old stuff from me
(Turn on your speakers
)

@NRx Hardstyle, as Soundphase said, really like the second melody

here's some old stuff from me


-
- State Newcomer
- Posts: 15
- Joined: 11 Aug 2016, 10:37
@Krystaal I really like teasing and the vocals u should turn this demo to full. Krystal Island sounds very emotional, u should improve the lead a little bit,the vocal fits perfect the theme (imo turn up the volume of the vocals a bit). Anyways i really like that kind of emotional hardstyle
.
Here is my unmastered demo.

Here is my unmastered demo.
HeyTragonvalo wrote:Hi !
Very nice old schoolish melo !
Here are some melodies i have made recently using fl studio 12
would love to hear any feedback !![]()
PS:Second Melody is the part 2 of first melody

I really like the last melody, has a special touch

Edit: and the one above, ofc this is amateurish as it can get, but you still feel the 2008ish vibe haha
- NRx Hardstyle
- State Citizen
- Posts: 172
- Joined: 26 Oct 2013, 20:48
- Location: Turku, Finland
@Krystaal; I do like the landscape melo best, it could use a bit more work tho. But a good start nonetheless.
@Tragonvalo: Some of the melos are not in the same scale as the rest of the melo(?), tho the third melo is pretty good on its own. Also as grape pointed out, really 2008 vibe.
Probably my next track, dont know yet
@Tragonvalo: Some of the melos are not in the same scale as the rest of the melo(?), tho the third melo is pretty good on its own. Also as grape pointed out, really 2008 vibe.
Probably my next track, dont know yet
https://soundcloud.com/Exinfinium
Check out my new Channelhttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXSnKw ... 5Ei4nhLklw
Check out my new Channelhttps://www.youtube.com/channel/UCXSnKw ... 5Ei4nhLklw
-
- State Celebrity
- Posts: 1923
- Joined: 20 Mar 2011, 14:41
@NRx soundcloud link doesn't seem to be valid
I made this hardcore melody that I like but I'm worried that it might give people a really bad feeling, what's your opinion?
I made this hardcore melody that I like but I'm worried that it might give people a really bad feeling, what's your opinion?
Purpose, thou art the compass.
@Krystaal - I love your track progression! You certainly know what you're doing there, you seem to make good use of vocals aswell! Just make sure you dont have to much high on your melodies or too much sidechain because sometimes you can't hear the melody over the static - harder to appreciate it 
@TheConvicted - No. 2 an 3 stick with those! They sound lovely!
@Soundphase - I like it man!
So i have 2 melodies but not sure which one to use in the format of the track. What do you guys think?
OR

@TheConvicted - No. 2 an 3 stick with those! They sound lovely!
@Soundphase - I like it man!
So i have 2 melodies but not sure which one to use in the format of the track. What do you guys think?
OR
-
- State Celebrity
- Posts: 1923
- Joined: 20 Mar 2011, 14:41
@izkliegt I like the 2nd one more, the first one isn't for me, good kicks as well
my ideas
my ideas
Purpose, thou art the compass.
@Soundphase
I pretty like the 2nd and 3rd one, but over all the last one, pretty well made, and I like the effects behind it ! The first one is particular, sounds a bit like a melody that could be in a The Prodigy track imo, well made but not really my cup of tea, keep working on these !
Ok, I've made something today, but I'm pretty sure that it was already made before, so I'm stuck at this point : I like it but I don't wanna make a track out of it if it has been already made by someone else...
I pretty like the 2nd and 3rd one, but over all the last one, pretty well made, and I like the effects behind it ! The first one is particular, sounds a bit like a melody that could be in a The Prodigy track imo, well made but not really my cup of tea, keep working on these !
Ok, I've made something today, but I'm pretty sure that it was already made before, so I'm stuck at this point : I like it but I don't wanna make a track out of it if it has been already made by someone else...